Sketchy Toms River Land Sale Traces Back to Completely Anonymous LLC

TOMS RIVER, NJ – A land sale by the township council of Toms River and Mayor Maurice Hill is getting more sketchy by the day. Today, we received the incorporation papers for the LLC that bought a 1.2 acre commercial property from the township and found the purchaser is a completely anonymous entity.

1810 Hinds Road LLC bought the $750,000 tract of land for just $250,000 at an auction where the highest of two bidders made a bid of $318,000.  Today, those LLC papers from the state showed the LLC as having no actual person behind it, except simply, “1810 Hinds Road LLC”.

We have submitted a Freedom of Information Act request from the US Postal Service to find the name behind the anonymous PO box behind the sale.

According to Toms River Mayor Maurice Hill, a fire sale land auction that sold a property assessed by the township for $750,000 has been sold to an anonymous post office box owned by an unnamed LLC on the Lakewood-Toms River border that operates out of a UPS store.

To make matters worse, pending data released today by the township regarding the reassessment, that land might have been worth as much as $1,000,000 on the open market as it’s prime real estate to be developed for a commercial strip mall. In fact, it’s one of two properties left within the Hooper Avenue commercial corridor from Southshore Drive north towards Brick that can be developed.  The other is a lot sandwiched between Walgreens and the Alpha Medical Center plaza. That land itself is assessed well over one-million dollars and is owned by an LLC with an address that traces back to the nearby Silverton Funeral Home, one of Mo Hill’s campaign donors.

We’re not sure who the lucky person behind the anonymous LLC is just yet, but we will be receiving that information from the State of New Jersey any minute now and we’ll release it as soon as we find out.

The property will have a negative impact for residential homeowners on Hinds Road.  Twelve homes in all line the road from Church Road to Polhemus Drive, used as a cut-through commercial drive and to for drivers looking to avoid traffic at the Church Road/Hooper Avenue intersection.   Now, with a new strip mall or other building being constructed on that land traffic would increase for those homeowners.

Breaking News:  Two flown to trauma center after SUV overturned in Manchester

Additionally, four homeowners on Greenwood Drive would see the land now owned by Toms River clear cut with a strip mall in their backyards.  Those home now see a line of trees and township owned land from their back porches.   After the sale and development of this property, they could be facing the ass end of a strip mall, complete with garbage dumpsters and cars parked along their backyard fence.

Last week, Toms River Mayor Maurice Hill announced that township appraisals in his town could be at least 21% under their real values.  With that being said, a piece of land appraised by the township on Hinds Road that was recently sold at auction to a developer for $250,000, according township records, could be worth as much as one  million dollars.  The land, previously assessed by Toms River for $750,000, according to Hill’s account could be worth as much as one million dollars in the new reassessment coming this September.

Who is the mystery buyer of the fire sale auction held by Mo Hill and the Toms River council? We’ll know shortly as we’re waiting for the state to deliver the LLC documents today. 

The property, which now presents a natural land buffer between the commercial growth on Hinds Road and Hooper Avenue will undoubtedly be turned into a commercial space.  It was purchased by the town to curb the commercial growth in that neighborhood, but now, is being used by the Hill administration to balance the budget.  But at what expense?  Hinds Road and the Stonehedge development for years has been used as a cut-through for commercial traffic seeking to circumvent traffic at the Church Road and Hooper Avenue intersection.   It has become a secondary commercial thoroughfare for homeowners on Hinds Road as the commercial development began to creep down the road years ago from the intersection of Hinds Road and Church Road.  A new plaza, a medical center and the construction of a large Walgreens to replace the former aging strip mall that once stood at the corner of Church and Hooper.

Breaking News:  Beachwood suspicious vehicle call turns into drug arrest

Another shopping plaza behind the already busy Hooper Avenue corridor would bring more traffic for homeowners on Hinds Road.   After Team Hill sells that property, there will be one last tract of wooded land available for development on Hooper Avenue from Brick Township south to Southshore Drive.  That is a 1.5 acre wooded corner that sits sandwiched between the Alpha Medical Plaza and Walgreens.   That land is owned by an LLC that uses Silverton Memorial Funeral Home as its address.

Twelve homes on Hinds Road will be affected by an increase in daily commercial traffic on the residential side street that connects Polhemus Drive to Church Road.  Four homeowners on Greenwood Road will see clearcutting to their fences.  Where they now look at wooded land, protected by the township, they would soon be staring at the back of a strip mall, possibly with dumpsters behind each unit and cars parked along their back yard fence should this sale be officially adopted by the town council.

Why did the town sell the highly valuable commercial property, one of the last remaining untouched lots along the already congested Hooper Avenue commercial corridor sell the land, which could have brought $1,000,000 perhaps on the open market, according to the Hill team’s latest assessment by his business administrator and fellow council members, “Currently the total assessed value of all properties in Toms River is $12,909,498,560 whereas the true equalized value is $16,264,959,758.  79%.”

Last week, Toms River Mayor Mo Hill and Council President Maria Maruca announced that the township has sold a 1-acre tract of publicly owned land to a potential real estate developer that operates anonymously out of a post office box at the UPS Store near the Lakewood-Toms River border.  The sale caught the attention of Toms River Councilman Daniel Rodrick who voted to table a resolution that would have memorialized that sale.

“I have serious concerns with this sale and the documents that were presented to me as a councilman,” Rodrick said today. “It appears there are a number of areas where the law may have been violated and I will be investigating the matter further.”

The sale, which the township kept under the radar and hidden in an obscure resolution on Tuesday raises questions as Toms River is running out of open space quickly.  Should the township begin selling off township-owned land to real estate developers?

Breaking News:  Man stabbed in Brick ShopRite parking lot, suspect on the run

Rodrick said no.

The sale is a sudden shift from the campaign message of Mayor Maurice Hill and his councilmen, Matt Lotano, Josh Kopp and Kevin Geoghegan.  That team ran on a platform to stop overdevelopment, although it has been pushing for high-density development downtown and in other areas of town since taking office.  Last month, the council approved a high density North Dover development by passing a zoning ordinance that doubled the number of homes on the Hecht-Lipshitz development.  The town council in 2018 changed zoning on that land, but the new council this year undid that zoning change.

The Hill team has also been working behind the scenes to modify the 10-acre house of worship zoning to allow for smaller lot houses of worship in North Dover and other sections of town.  Hill now has Democrat backing on that front but knows it would be an unpopular move with voters.


As for the Hinds Road land sale, that remains up in the air after being challenged by Rodrick.

The 1870 Hinds Road lot however is zoned highway commercial according to the township zoning map.  A comparable commercial lot next to the 1870 property carries an $825,000 land value assessment by the township.

The auction took place from Monday, June 22nd at 9 am and ended on Wednesday, June 24 at 2:00 pm.  The buyer of the property is 1810 Hinds LLC.  According to New Jersey state records, that LLC was actually formed four days later, on June 26th.  1810 Hinds Road has a mailing address that tracks back to an unmarked UPS store post office box located in the Tri-City Plaza on the border of Toms River and Lakewood.

The council decided to pull the vote from the agenda and the matter will be heard on August 11th after a unanimous vote by the township council.  The name of the person behind 1810 Hinds LLC has not been disclosed.