Here are the top 10 highest-rated pizzas in Toms River

1 min read
Brooklyn Square Pizza rated highest pizzeria in Toms River by One Bite Pizza App users. Photo by Kathleen Lynam/Brooklyn Square Pizza - Facebook.

TOMS RIVER, NJ – There’s no shortage of pizzerias in Toms River, but only a handful can truly be considered the best in town. Now, the One Bite Pizza app designed by Barstool Sports helps finding the best pizza in town ever before.

In Toms River, 10 pizzerias stack up to criticism and are the top 10 highest-rated pizzerias on the popular pizza review app. Unfortunately, Dave Portnoy, CEO of Barstool Sports and pizzeria maker and breaker has never reviewed a Toms River pizza, but has visited nearby Jackson and the boardwalk in Seaside Heights.

Brooklyn Square – 9.0

Brooklyn Square is located in the old Pizza Rustico spot in Silverton, just off Church Road. While Portnoy never visited Brooklyn Square in Toms River, he did visit with owner Peter Grippo at his flagship restaurant in Jackson, where he handed their signature square pizza an 8.9 and gave the plain round cheese pizza a 7.8.

Zi Marie’s Original Pizzeria-Trattoria – 8.6

Zi Marie’s in known for good pizza and good service and the pizza critics have spoken by voting it the second best pizza in Toms River. Zi Marie’s is located just outside of Holiday City Berkeley on Jamaica Boulevard.

DiCosmo’s Pizza – 8.5

The vote is out whether or not their round cheese pie or upside-down grandma pie was the best, but one thing Toms River agrees on is that DiCosmo’s was ranked the third best pizza in town. DiComsos had large shoes to fill, taking over the old Steverino’s spot, a place that fed generations of Silverton residents until they closed up for good. The restaurant announced its closure in September, unfortunately.

Naples Pizza & Restaurant – 7.4

Known for much more than pizza, Naples managed to score 7.4 on the One Bite App and 4.8 on slice life. You can find Naples Pizzeria at the corner of Fischer Boulevard and Windsor Avenue.

Breaking News:  Amber alert issued for Baltimore 13-year-old missing since Friday

Attilio’s Pizza – 7.4

Since 1973, Attilios has been feeding generations of Toms River and is the oldest operating pizzeria in town. Located on Route 166 just across from the Shop-Rite plaza, Attilio’s, if nothing else, is consistently delivering on its promise of great quality food and delicious pizza.

Here are the next five top-rated Toms River pizzerias on the One Bite Pizza App.

Capone’s – 7.3
Mia’s Pizza 37 – 7.2
Cathy’s Ristorante – 7.2
Dario Pasta Pannini – 7.1
Al’s Famous Pizza – 7.1

Do you agree? Let us know your favorite Toms River pizza in the comments below.