TRENTON, N.J. – This is what New Jersey voters voted for just weeks ago, complete control of the state government by one party with no oversight.
Now, the party is moving to disarm the state’s most prominent political corruption investigative arm.
Just days before Thanksgiving, Senate President Nick Scutari moved a sweeping bill that would quietly dissolve the Office of the State Comptroller’s investigative arm and transfer its powers to the State Commission of Investigation (SCI).
The bill, introduced and scheduled with little public notice, claims to “eliminate duplication” among New Jersey’s oversight agencies.
If passed, it would effectively end all ongoing investigations by the Office of the State Comptroller (OSC) and consolidate oversight authority under the SCI.
Critics are already calling the measure a blow to government transparency and a step backward for accountability in Trenton.
Bill consolidates oversight power under one agency
Under the proposal, the SCI would absorb all functions currently handled by the OSC’s investigative division, including those of the former Office of the Inspector General and the Medicaid Inspector General. Lawmakers behind the bill say it follows a 2010 effort to streamline government oversight, arguing it will improve efficiency and coordination between agencies.
The measure also expands the SCI’s authority, giving it new powers to investigate misconduct by state and local government personnel and to serve as a de facto inspector general for New Jersey. The SCI’s executive director would formally assume that inspector general role.
Transparency advocates raise alarm over timing and motive
Government watchdogs and some legislators have questioned the timing of the bill, which was introduced just before a major holiday when public attention is low. Opponents argue the move allows lawmakers to avoid scrutiny while pushing through a bill that limits independent oversight.
They warn that transferring investigative control to the SCI—a body whose commissioners are appointed by political leadership—could compromise the independence that the OSC has maintained since its inception.
Increased pay for commission members draws criticism
The bill would also raise SCI commissioner salaries from $35,000 to $75,000 per year, a detail that has drawn further criticism from fiscal watchdogs who argue the legislation benefits insiders rather than taxpayers. Proponents contend the increase reflects the expanded workload and responsibilities that would come with the agency’s new authority.
Historical justification meets modern skepticism
Supporters point to the Forsythe Committee’s 1968 recommendations, which envisioned a unified oversight body with broad investigative powers. But opponents argue that more centralization means less transparency and fewer checks on political power in state government.
If approved, the bill would redefine New Jersey’s oversight structure—potentially closing active OSC probes and granting the SCI a larger, more politically connected role in policing corruption.
The proposal consolidates power under the State Commission of Investigation while raising concerns about lost transparency and weakened watchdog independence.