ROCKINGHAM, N.C. — Joseph Ray Carroll, 54, was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole for the murder of his girlfriend’s 15-year-old son, Casey Johnson. Carroll received the sentence after being convicted of first-degree murder and two counts of felony child abuse last week.
The incident leading to the conviction occurred in 2021. Prosecutors stated Carroll killed Johnson by repeatedly banging his head against the floor. The assault occurred while the victim’s younger sister witnessed the event.
Richmond County District Attorney Jamie Adams addressed the case, stating, “I cannot adequately express the horrors these children experienced at the hands of this defendant.” She noted the long-lasting impact it has had on the children involved, the jurors, and the community.
Casey’s mother, Michelle Johnson, initially admitted to injuring her son but later became the subject of a courtroom video showing Carroll instructing her to align their narratives. Johnson faces charges of accessory after the fact and felony child abuse.
Child abuse experts described Casey’s injuries as comparable to those sustained in a car accident. Reports indicated that Carroll had subjected Casey and his two younger sisters to dehydration, beatings, and sleep deprivation during a two-year period.
Testimony from Casey’s sister revealed the lasting trauma inflicted by Carroll. She stated, “Joe made us so weak so that we couldn’t fight back,” indicating the psychological and physical damage caused by Carroll.
Following the court ruling, the sisters have been placed in the custody of their aunt and uncle. Family members expressed belief that Casey would be pleased with the verdict, as it provides safety for his sisters.