In a recent ruling, a federal appeals court supported the decision of Nichols Middle School in Middleborough, Massachusetts, to send student Liam Morrison home for wearing a T-shirt deemed demeaning to nonbinary students. The incidents began when 12-year-old Morrison wore a shirt stating “There Are Only Two Genders” following the school’s celebration of Pride Day.
The school argued that the shirt targeted nonbinary students, prompting them to send Morrison home to maintain a safe and inclusive environment. This action led to further public demonstrations by both supporters and opponents of the school’s decision, sparking significant local controversy.
Morrison, backed by the conservative group Alliance Defending Freedom, subsequently filed a lawsuit claiming that the school’s actions violated his First Amendment rights. However, the appeals court sided with the school, citing the need to prevent disruptions and protect the rights and safety of all students.
This case highlights the ongoing debate over free speech in schools and the balance between individual rights and maintaining an educational environment free from discrimination and harassment.