It’s been two decades since the abrupt fade-to-black that left millions of viewers stunned, and the question still haunts fans and locals alike: Who killed Tony Soprano?
On June 10, 2007, the final episode of HBO’s groundbreaking series The Sopranos aired, concluding with an enigmatic scene at Holsten’s Diner in Bloomfield, New Jersey.
The show’s protagonist, mob boss Tony Soprano, sat with his family, onion rings on the table, as Journey’s “Don’t Stop Believin’” played on the jukebox. Then, in an instant, the screen cut to black, leaving his fate—and the identity of any potential killer—forever unresolved.
Holsten’s Diner, a cozy, retro eatery that became an unlikely cultural landmark, remains a pilgrimage site for fans. On any given weekend, tourists snap photos outside the unassuming brick building, some even sitting in the booth where Tony, Carmela, and A.J. shared their final moments on screen.
The diner’s owners, who still serve up the famous onion rings, say the fascination hasn’t faded.
People come from all over—Japan, Germany, you name it. They sit in that booth, order onion rings, and argue about what happened. Was it the guy in the Members Only jacket? The Russians? Or maybe nobody at all? It’s like a religion now.
The ambiguity of the ending, crafted by Sopranos creator David Chase, has fueled endless debate. Chase has remained cryptic over the years, once saying in a 2019 interview, “Death is always on the table, but it’s not about the ending—it’s about life’s uncertainty.”
Fans have dissected every frame of the scene: the suspicious man at the counter, the bell ringing as the diner door opened, Meadow’s struggle to parallel park. Theories range from a hit ordered by rival New York mobsters to an internal betrayal by one of Tony’s own crew, like Paulie Walnuts or Patsy Parisi.
Some even speculate the FBI, having dogged Tony for years, might have orchestrated a takedown.
The cut to black is us, the audience, getting whacked.
The mystery has kept The Sopranos alive in pop culture. Social media platforms like X are flooded with fan threads rehashing theories, especially around the anniversary of the finale.
A 2025 Reddit poll showed 62% of 10,000 respondents believe Tony was killed, while 28% think he survived, and 10% insist the ending was deliberately open-ended.
Academic papers, documentaries, and even a 2021 prequel film, The Many Saints of Newark, have tried to unpack the show’s legacy, but none have settled the debate.Holsten’s itself has leaned into the legacy.
The booth where the Sopranos sat is marked with a small plaque that reads, “Reserved for the Soprano Family.”
The jukebox still plays Journey, and the diner sells “Soprano Special” merchandise, including T-shirts emblazoned with “What Happened to Tony?” For Bloomfield locals, the attention is a point of pride, though some are weary of the endless speculation.
As the sun sets over Bloomfield, Holsten’s neon sign glows, a beacon for those still chasing answers. Was Tony Soprano gunned down in that diner? Did he live to fight another day? Two decades later, the truth remains as elusive as a mobster slipping into witness protection. For now, the mystery—and the onion rings—keep fans coming back, hoping to crack the case that David Chase left unsolved.