New York, NY – A federal judge in Manhattan has issued a split ruling in an international contract dispute between three Chinese textile manufacturers and several American fashion importers linked to the late businessman Billy Chen. While the court dismissed certain claims, most of the lawsuit will proceed toward trial.
U.S. District Judge Dale E. Ho of the Southern District of New York granted in part and denied in part motions to dismiss filed by defendants Global Fashion Icon, Inc. and Jeanette Lau. The plaintiffs, Dongguan Guankun Trading Co., Ltd., Dongguan Zhuoying Apparel Co., Ltd., and Dongguan Zhuosheng Textile Co., Ltd., allege the defendants failed to pay for large shipments of yarn and apparel delivered to the United States.
The complaint claims that Chen’s companies operated as intermediaries, purchasing goods from the Chinese firms on behalf of U.S. retailers. Once the products arrived in American warehouses, the plaintiffs say, payment never followed. The alleged unpaid transactions form the basis for claims including breach of contract, breach of good faith and fair dealing, and unjust enrichment.
Judge Ho dismissed the fraud and rescission claims, ruling they lacked the specificity required by federal pleading standards. However, he allowed the core contract and enrichment claims to move forward, along with allegations that the defendants functioned as corporate alter egos to avoid financial obligations.
Dispute highlights global apparel trade tensions
Court filings describe a network of more than ten U.S.-based corporate entities formed by Chen, some registered to his parents and other relatives. Plaintiffs allege these companies shifted ownership and funds among themselves to conceal liability. Co-defendant Jeanette Lau, identified as CEO of two of the corporate defendants, argued for dismissal, but the court ruled questions surrounding her role must be addressed through discovery.
- Fraud and rescission claims were dismissed
- Contract and unjust enrichment claims proceed
- Plaintiffs allege millions owed for apparel shipments
With the decision, the case now advances to discovery, where both sides will exchange documents and testimony related to the alleged nonpayment and corporate control. The outcome could determine whether Chen’s estate and his network of fashion import firms face significant financial liability in the United States.