Strange but true: unforgettable encounters on nyc subways
NYC subway car - File Photo

Strange but True: Unforgettable Encounters on NYC Subways

August 28, 2023

New York, NY — While New York City’s subway system is often in the spotlight for its issues regarding safety and maintenance, the underground world of the MTA can also serve as a stage for the unexpected, odd, and sometimes jaw-dropping. New Yorkers recently took to Quora to share their most extraordinary subway stories, detailing encounters that range from comical to unsettling.

  1. A fully nude woman, save for a headscarf, casually walked through a crowded train, prompting riders to quickly make way. Her presence caused a train delay while police conducted a search.
  2. One passenger described an alarming sight of liquid continuously flowing down the middle of a B train car, only to discover it was originating from a homeless individual at the back. The description likened the fountain-like emission to Bethesda Fountain.
  3. A commuter found a cleanly severed, white finger wrapped in a stained handkerchief on a subway platform after transferring from a PATH train. The shocking discovery was left behind as the individual boarded the next train.
  4. A violent altercation broke out between two men dressed as women and a woman, allegedly over comments about hair weaves. Bystanders eventually intervened to break up the fight.
  5. A ventriloquist brought levity to a late-night ride by opening a suitcase to reveal a dummy, which then insulted passengers. The unexpected performance captivated 40-50 commuters, who were entertained during their journey.

These accounts remind us that the NYC subway can be a theatre of the strange and the bizarre, capturing the eclectic and sometimes surreal nature of life in the Big Apple.

Adam Devine

Adam Devine

Adam covers New York City and regional news for Shore News Network. He is currently attending college and freelances about crime in New York City and regional news.