Nestled along the vibrant Jersey Shore, Burger 25 has rapidly emerged as a beloved destination for burger enthusiasts, locals, and tourists alike.
With its fresh ingredients, creative menu, and family-owned charm, this burger joint is redefining what a burger joint can be at the Jersey Shore.
From its original Toms River location to its expanding footprint in Ship Bottom and Brick, Burger 25 is quickly becoming the go-to spot for a mouthwatering meal.
Since opening its doors in Toms River in 2013, Burger 25 has built its reputation on one simple promise: to serve the best burgers you’ve ever tasted. The secret? Fresh, high-quality ingredients. Their burgers are made daily with Certified Hereford Beef, never frozen, ensuring a juicy and flavorful bite every time.
“Everything’s fresh,” the company boasts, “Everything comes in daily. We use quality Angus, and all of our sauces are homemade.”
What sets Burger 25 apart is its extensive menu, boasting 25 unique burger options alongside chicken sandwiches, hot dogs, wings, fresh salads, and hand-spun milkshakes.
From the classic cheeseburger with American cheese, lettuce, tomato, and pickles to inventive creations like the Reef and Beef (topped with pepper jack, shredded lettuce, and crispy rock shrimp in a spicy Gojuchang sauce) or the Brew House Burger (served on a Bavarian pretzel roll with beer cheese), there’s something for every palate. Their monthly specialty burgers, often crafted in collaboration with local businesses, keep the menu exciting and fresh.
Burger 25 also caters to diverse tastes with vegan and vegetarian options, ensuring everyone can enjoy their offerings. The menu’s variety, combined with prices competitive with fast-food chains, has earned raves from customers.
One reviewer called it “hands down the best burger place I’ve ever been to,” citing the extensive menu and affordable prices.
Expanding Horizons: From Toms River to LBI and Beyond
Burger 25’s journey began at 1611 Route 37 East in Toms River, where it quickly became a local favorite. Outgrowing its original space, the family-owned business expanded to Ship Bottom in June 2023, taking over a former eatery just off Ocean County Road 607.
This new spot, open year-round from 11 AM to 11 PM, features a walk-up milkshake window—a perfect addition for those hot summer days on Long Beach Island (LBI).
Unlike many LBI eateries that shutter in the off-season, Burger 25’s commitment to staying open year-round has made it a reliable choice for locals and visitors alike.
In August 2024, Burger 25 opened its third location in Brick at 2045 Route 88, further solidifying its presence at the Jersey Shore.
The Brick restaurant, located next to a local brewery, offers a unique synergy where brewery patrons can order from Burger 25, and restaurant customers can enjoy craft brews with their meal. The vibrant atmosphere, complete with doodle art, big-screen TVs, arcade games, and a quirky telephone pole strung with colorful decorations, adds to the fun, family-friendly vibe.
Community Roots and Customer Loyalty
At its core, Burger 25 is a family affair. Owned and operated by Denise and Steve Vetter, along with their children, the business prides itself on creating a welcoming environment. Their hands-on approach—Denise often greets customers, while Steve oversees operations—has fostered a loyal following.
Social media buzz, particularly on platforms like Instagram, showcases glowing reviews and mouthwatering photos of their burgers, shakes, and fries.
Customers rave about the quick service, generous portions, and the ability to customize orders, making Burger 25 a standout in a sea of chain restaurants.
The Vetters’ commitment to the Jersey Shore community also shines through. By partnering with local businesses for specialty burgers and staying open year-round, Burger 25 has become a staple for both summer crowds and off-season locals. Their focus on quality and consistency has earned them accolades, including being named “Best Burger” in Ocean County by various local polls.
Why Burger 25 is the Jersey Shore’s Go-To
Burger 25’s meteoric rise can be attributed to its winning formula: fresh, high-quality ingredients, an inventive and inclusive menu, and a family-oriented atmosphere that resonates with the Jersey Shore’s laid-back vibe.
Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch in Toms River, enjoying a milkshake by the beach in Ship Bottom, or pairing a burger with a craft beer in Brick, Burger 25 delivers an experience that keeps customers coming back for more.
As the Jersey Shore’s culinary scene continues to evolve, Burger 25 stands out as a beacon of flavor, creativity, and community spirit. If you haven’t yet sunk your teeth into one of their burgers, it’s time to see why this family-owned gem is quickly becoming the go-to burger joint at the Jersey Shore.
