In honor of National Pizza Day, there’s no better time to explore the best pizza spots in Toms River, New Jersey. Whether you crave a classic New York slice, a thick Sicilian square, or a gourmet pie, this town has some fantastic options. Here are five top-rated pizzerias that are serving up some of the best slices in Ocean County.
Slice House: A Must-Visit for Pizza Lovers
With a stellar 4.6-star rating, Slice House has earned a reputation among pizza connoisseurs. Patrons rave about their expertly crafted slices, with crispy-yet-chewy crusts and the perfect cheese-to-sauce ratio. This spot has even drawn in pizza enthusiasts on a New Jersey pizza crawl, solidifying its place as a top contender. Whether you opt for a classic Margherita or a specialty slice, Slice House is a must-visit for a true pizza experience.
Verace’s Pizza: Where Quality Meets Tradition
Verace’s Pizza holds a solid 4.3-star rating, and locals can’t stop talking about its incredible flavors. This pizzeria is not only a go-to spot for a quick slice but also a trusted name for catering. The menu boasts a mix of traditional and creative options, making it a great choice for those who appreciate both classic pies and inventive toppings. If you’re looking for a place with a hip yet welcoming vibe, Verace’s is a fantastic choice.
Sal’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria: Old-School Charm with a Modern Twist
For those who love a casual and cozy Italian dining experience, Sal’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria is a must-try. With a 4.2-star rating, customers praise their consistently delicious pizza and welcoming atmosphere. The menu extends beyond pizza, offering Italian favorites that make it a great spot for a family dinner. One reviewer even claimed it’s the best pizza they’ve had in New Jersey—next to Nonna’s, of course!
Brooklyn Square Pizza: The Destination for a New York-Style Slice
If you’re on the hunt for a taste of Brooklyn in Toms River, Brooklyn Square Pizza has you covered. With a 3.6-star rating, this pizzeria has garnered a dedicated following for its signature square pies. The dough is perfectly airy, the sauce is rich and flavorful, and the cheese melts into a gooey masterpiece. Pair that with friendly service, and it’s no wonder why this spot keeps customers coming back.
Italy’s Best III: More Than Just Pizza
Earning a 4.3-star rating, Italy’s Best III is a hidden gem offering more than just incredible pizza. Customers rave about their wings and garlic knots, making it an ideal stop for a full Italian feast. The pizza itself is praised for its fresh ingredients and balanced flavors, making it one of Ocean County’s top choices for a satisfying slice.
Whether you’re a lifelong local or just passing through, Toms River has plenty of fantastic pizzerias to explore. Celebrate National Pizza Day by grabbing a slice (or a whole pie) from one of these beloved spots. No matter your preference, you’re bound to find a pizza that hits the spot in this Jersey Shore town.
