New jersey's top epidemiologist says contact tracing doesn't really work the way murphy says it does

New Jersey’s Top Epidemiologist Says Contact Tracing Doesn’t Really Work the Way Murphy Says it Does

TRENTON, NJ – For months, Governor Phil Murphy has been touting contact tracing as one of the tools to stop the spread of COVID-19 in New Jersey by having thousands of healthcare workers making phone calls to determine contacts and how a person may have contracted the virus.

On Wednesday, State Epidemiologist Dr. Christina Tan said that’s not exactly how it all works.

“Well, I think the other thing that we have to keep in mind is that a lot of times we won’t necessarily know what might be the source definitively of an individual’s infection with SARS COV-2 (COVID-19), and while we can make association sometimes between a contact and a particular case, probably I would say the vast majority of our cases you’ll never know what the actual source is,” Dr. Tan said.  “Because the fact is, as long as you have SARS COV-2 virus in the community, it’s going to be kind of hard to necessarily pinpoint where a person might have become infected.”

With failures in the contact tracing system in New Jersey, such as people not answering phone calls and refusing to give the Governor’s 1,700 or so contact tracers any information, that adds to the ineffectiveness of the initiative.

“For COVID-19, a close contact is defined as any individual who was within 6 feet of an infected person for at least 15 minutes starting from 2 days before illness onset (or, for asymptomatic patients, 2 days prior to positive specimen collection) until the time the patient is isolated,” according to the CDC.  “The public health evaluation of close contacts to patients with laboratory-confirmed or probable COVID-19 may vary depending on the exposure setting. Contacts in special populations and/or congregate settings require additional considerations and may need handoff to a senior health department investigator or special team.”

The CDC has not implemented a national contact tracing strategy, instead, it left the decisions on how to implement contact tracing up to the individual states.

Contact tracers use clear protocols to notify, interview, and advise close contacts to patients with confirmed or probable COVID-19 the CDC said.

“Implementing a robust contact tracing program is a key mechanism to break the chain of transmission and slow community spread for individuals who have come into contact with those infected by COVID-19. New Jersey will implement the following strategies to build a comprehensive contact tracing program,” Murphy said in May when he announced his plan for a large corps of contact tracers. “Implementing an expanded testing regime and robust contact tracing strategy are the underpinnings of putting New Jersey on the road back to recovery. Public health creates economic health and today’s plan will give our residents and business owners confidence that the state is prepared to move forward strategically and responsibly.”

Photo by Hassan OUAJBIR on Unsplash

Shore News Network Staff Report

Shore News Network Staff Report is the official newsroom byline used by Shore News Network when a story is produced through the collaborative work of multiple members of the editorial team rather than a single reporter.

This newsroom account is reserved for articles that involve contributions from multiple journalists, editors, photographers, researchers, or news desk staff. It is also used for developing stories that are updated as new verified information becomes available, as well as for community announcements, weather coverage, public safety alerts, election results, and other newsroom-produced content.

Every article published under the Shore News Network Staff Report byline is reviewed and edited in accordance with the organization's editorial standards for accuracy, fairness, attribution, and transparency. Information is verified through official government agencies, court records, law enforcement, public documents, direct reporting, interviews, and other reliable primary and secondary sources before publication whenever possible.

The Staff Report account does not use artificial intelligence to independently generate news or publish unverified information. AI-assisted tools may occasionally be used for editorial support tasks such as transcription, formatting, grammar review, or workflow efficiency, but all published content is subject to human editorial oversight and approval by Shore News Network's newsroom staff.

As an independently owned digital news organization, Shore News Network is committed to original reporting, public safety journalism, government accountability, local community coverage, and breaking news throughout New Jersey and surrounding regions. Stories published under the Staff Report byline reflect the collective experience and editorial judgment of the Shore News Network newsroom.

Readers who have corrections, additional information, or news tips related to a Staff Report article are encouraged to contact the newsroom at news@shorenewsnetwork.com. Shore News Network welcomes factual corrections and updates as part of its commitment to accurate, transparent journalism.