TEANECK, NJ – A New York man wanted on multiple burglary warrants has been arrested in connection with a series of vehicle break-ins in Teaneck, authorities announced Monday.
According to Teaneck Police Chief Andrew R. McGurr, Michael Cokley of Middletown, New York, was taken into custody following an investigation into several vehicle burglaries that occurred in the southern section of town during the early morning hours of December 6, 2025.
Between 3:00 a.m. and 5:00 a.m., six vehicles were burglarized in the areas of Copley Avenue, Oakdene Avenue, Herrick Avenue, and Degraw Avenue. Residents reported security footage showing a suspect attempting to open car doors, with one video capturing activity around 4:02 a.m. Police said stolen items included wallets, electronics, cash, identification cards, and credit cards.
Detectives collected a significant amount of surveillance video from residents, which helped identify Cokley as the suspect. The arrest was made with assistance from multiple law enforcement agencies.
Cokley has been charged with six counts of burglary (third degree), one count of theft (third degree), and two counts of credit card theft (fourth degree).
Key Points: New York man arrested in connection with Teaneck vehicle burglaries, police say – Teaneck
- Michael Cokley of Middletown, N.Y., arrested for multiple vehicle burglaries in Teaneck
- Six cars were burglarized in the early hours of December 6 in the town’s southern section
- Detectives used home surveillance footage to identify and charge the suspect