PHILADELPHIA, PA – A significant legal milestone was achieved as a Philadelphia jury convicted ex-homicide detective James Pitts of multiple charges, including obstruction and perjury, for his involvement in a wrongful conviction case. District Attorney Larry Krasner announced the verdict on Tuesday, highlighting the historical significance of this case within the city.
In 2010, Pitts assaulted suspect Obina Onyiah during an investigation, which led to a false confession to the robbery-murder of William Glatz at Glatz Jewelry Store in Lawncrest. Pitts later lied about the assault in 2013 during a pretrial motion and jury trial, actions for which he has now been found guilty of two counts each of obstruction and perjury.
This conviction traces back to an investigation by the Thirty-First County Investigating Grand Jury in 2022 and underscores systemic issues in law enforcement practices. Onyiah, who served 11 years for a murder he did not commit, was exonerated in 2021 when new scientific evidence proved his innocence. The real perpetrator remains at large.
DA Krasner praised the jury for their just verdict and acknowledged the efforts of the Conviction Integrity Unit, particularly Chief Michael Garmisa and Assistant District Attorney Rebecca McDonald, for their role in prosecuting this landmark case. ADA Garmisa also expressed gratitude towards Onyiah for his testimony and commended the investigative support from various units and agencies.
James Pitts is scheduled for sentencing on October 4, 2024, in the Court of Common Pleas, marking a conclusive step in a case that underscores the importance of integrity and accountability within the criminal justice system.
