If you ever find yourself driving down Southwestern Boulevard in Orchard Park, New York, and spot a retro gas station with a Studebaker tow truck out front, you’ve just stumbled upon Route 20 Ice Cream—a place where vintage charm meets modern indulgence. Masquerading as a 1950s gas station, Route 20 offers a nostalgic escape that’s equal parts roadside attraction and ice cream haven.
This spot doesn’t just serve your typical cones and shakes, although they certainly do that with flair. Their menu is packed with endless options, from classic sundaes to health-conscious protein shakes and fruity smoothies. Even your furry friend isn’t left out, with the “Doggie Dish” featuring vanilla ice cream and doggie treats. It’s like they thought of everyone who might come by, whether you’re a sugar addict or just looking for a dairy-free delight. Vegans are covered with soy-based ice cream options like salty caramel and tiramisu, all under the brand “Temptation,” made with non-GMO ingredients.
The exterior might scream “fill ‘er up!” with its gas station facade, but it’s really a sweet tooth fueling stop. If the iconic red and white 1947 Studebaker tow truck doesn’t lure you in, maybe the restored 1903 caboose will. Sitting on faux tracks, the air-conditioned caboose is a cozy little nook where you can escape the summer heat and dive into a cone while perusing a stack of vintage Courier-Express magazines.
For the ultimate nostalgia overload, head out back to their “museum.” In what was once a garage, you’ll find a treasure trove of retro photos, vintage signs, and other Americana artifacts. It’s a quirky addition to your ice cream experience and a perfect backdrop for daydreams of yesteryear while munching on a scoop of house-made gelato. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick cone or taking time to explore the caboose and museum, Route 20 Ice Cream offers more than just frozen treats—it serves up a slice of vintage Americana that’ll keep you coming back for more.
