SEASIDE HEIGHTS, NJ – When it comes to the best pizza on the Seaside Heights Boardwalk, two legendary spots consistently draw rave reviews: Maruca’s Tomato Pies and The Sawmill. Both have deep roots in the local culinary scene, offering unique experiences that keep visitors coming back for more.
Maruca’s Tomato Pies, established in 1950, is considered a Jersey Shore institution. Known for its distinctively large pies with a signature spiral of cheese and tomato sauce, Maruca’s serves up a classic Trenton-style pizza. The sauce is spread in a swirl pattern, which ensures every bite has a balanced mix of cheese and tangy tomato.
The crust is thin and crispy, adding to the authentic boardwalk experience. Maruca’s charm extends beyond its pizza; it’s a piece of local history, making it a must-visit for anyone wanting an iconic slice at the Jersey Shore. Its reputation is bolstered by numerous awards and local polls naming it the best pizza on the boardwalk, and it remains a favorite for both tourists and long-time residents alike.
Just a short walk away is The Sawmill, another iconic spot famous for its jumbo pizza slices. Open since 1977, The Sawmill’s colossal slices have earned it a legendary status. Situated at the southern end of the boardwalk in Seaside Park, it offers a more extensive menu that goes beyond pizza, including sandwiches and local seafood, but the pizza is undoubtedly the star. The slices are not just large in size; they’re also big on flavor, with a thicker, softer crust that provides a different texture from Maruca’s crispy style. It’s a great spot for enjoying a slice while taking in the ocean views, making the experience as much about the atmosphere as the food.
While Maruca’s and The Sawmill are the most iconic, other contenders like Shore Slice add to the vibrant pizza scene. Shore Slice is known for its convenient location and classic New York-style slices, offering a reliable option for those looking for a quick and tasty bite.
Ultimately, choosing the best pizza on the boardwalk might come down to personal preference: Maruca’s offers a historic and uniquely styled slice, while The Sawmill is perfect for those who love oversized portions and a laid-back beach vibe. Whichever you choose, the boardwalk’s pizza culture ensures you won’t be disappointed.
In addition to Maruca’s Tomato Pies and The Sawmill, three other popular pizza spots on the Seaside Heights Boardwalk add to the vibrant pizza scene, each bringing its own charm and flavor.
Shore Slice Pizza & Grill is a beloved spot known for its New York-style pizza and classic boardwalk vibe. Located right on the boardwalk at 1309, Shore Slice serves large, foldable slices with a crisp yet chewy crust. The menu extends beyond traditional pizzas to offer unique items like buffalo chicken eggrolls and a variety of subs and salads, making it a versatile choice for a quick bite or a more leisurely meal. Its straightforward approach to quality pizza ensures it stays on the radar for locals and visitors alike.
Three Brothers From Italy Pizza stands out with its enormous slices that cater perfectly to the boardwalk crowd. Situated at 1005 Oceanfront, this spot is a staple for beachgoers looking to grab a slice on the go. The slices are not just massive but also pack a flavorful punch with a perfectly balanced cheese-to-sauce ratio and a slightly crunchy crust. With its casual atmosphere and reputation for delicious pizza, Three Brothers is often recommended by those who frequent the Jersey Shore.
Seaside Pizza and Grill, located at 200 Boardwalk, is a great year-round option offering a variety of classic and specialty pizzas. Known for its friendly atmosphere and authentic Italian flavors, this spot serves up pizzas with a light, crispy crust and fresh ingredients, making it a go-to for those seeking a traditional pizzeria experience on the boardwalk. Their menu also includes kid-friendly options and classic Italian dishes, ensuring there’s something for everyone.
These establishments, each with their unique style and atmosphere, contribute to Seaside Heights’ reputation for outstanding boardwalk pizza. Whether you crave Maruca’s iconic tomato pies, The Sawmill’s jumbo slices, or something in between, the boardwalk offers plenty of options to satisfy any pizza lover.
