If you grew up in Toms River, NJ, these beloved restaurants probably bring back memories of family dinners, birthday parties, and unforgettable meals. Though they’re no longer around, their legacies continue to live on in the hearts (and stomachs) of locals. Let’s dive into some of the most iconic spots that once defined the Toms River food scene.
The Ground Round
The Ground Round was a place where you could snack on peanuts and toss the shells on the floor without getting into trouble. It was a casual, fun, family-friendly restaurant offering burgers, popcorn, and a laid-back vibe perfect for watching a game or celebrating a birthday. Located near the Ocean County Mall, it was a popular spot for locals before closing its doors in the early 2000s.
What’s there now? B2 Bistro.
Old Time Tavern
A staple for decades, Old Time Tavern opened in the 1960s and closed in 2008. Known for its old-fashioned charm and hearty meals, it was the go-to spot for steak dinners, family gatherings, and even weddings. The restaurant also had a rich history—it was partially built from pieces of an 18th-century hotel that was relocated to avoid demolition.
Today, the site has been replaced by a Buffalo Wild Wings and some chain brands, but the memories of Old Time Tavern still linger for those who dined there.
Nick the Greek
Nick the Greek brought the flavors of Greece to Toms River with its mouthwatering gyros and souvlaki. The small, unassuming eatery was a hidden gem for Mediterranean food lovers, offering authentic Greek dishes that kept locals coming back. While Nick the Greek eventually closed, it remains a cherished memory for those who crave a taste of the Mediterranean on the Jersey Shore.
What’s there now? Aqua Blue.
Wolfie’s Deli
For more than 50 years, Wolfie’s Deli was the go-to spot for anyone craving a piled-high pastrami sandwich or a bowl of matzo ball soup. Located on Route 37, it was a classic Jewish deli with portions as big as its reputation. Unfortunately, Wolfie’s closed in 2019, leaving behind the memory of its towering sandwiches and beloved regulars.
What’s there now? A new shopping mall at their old location. Burger 25 is now at their last location.
JoJo’s Italian Hot Dogs
JoJo’s was the spot for a quick, satisfying meal when you were on the go. Famous for their Newark-style Italian hot dogs, JoJo’s served up fried hot dogs stuffed into Italian rolls and topped with sautéed onions, peppers, and potatoes. After decades of serving the Toms River community, JoJo’s closed in 2021 when the owner retired. But for those who grew up grabbing hot dogs there, the taste remains unforgettable.
Baimonte’s
If you ever had pizza at Baimonte’s, you know it set the bar for pizzerias in Toms River. Known for its perfectly crispy crust and tangy sauce, Baimonte’s wasn’t just a pizza place—it was an institution. Whether it was pizza night with the family or a casual dinner with friends, Baimonte’s had a loyal following. Though it’s no longer open, locals still rave about it as one of the best pizza joints the town has ever seen.
These restaurants may be gone, but their impact on Toms River’s dining scene is undeniable. The memories made in their booths and dining rooms live on, even as new spots emerge to take their place.
What’s there now? Empty.